· 8 items
Legislative Policy Committee, Monday, October 5
On the episode: Housing petition complaints, city cameras, and a split Rose Bowl vote
This episode was produced with AI from the public recordings of the week's meetings. Links to the sources are in the show notes.
What happened
Legislative Policy Committee Monday, October 5
8 items
The recording · 2026-10-05-Legislative-Policy-Committee-Meeting-Agenda-Notice
Federal legislative briefing Item 6
State and federal policyData centersAirports and aviation
The city's federal legislative advocate gave an update on Congress before the election recess: a stopgap funding measure, data center electricity legislation, a permitting reform deal, and the expired federal transportation bill, which funds highway, transit and rail programs. Information only; no action was taken. 00:06:57
- A speaker reported that Congress did not pass a new fiscal 2027 budget and instead passed a stopgap continuing resolution running through December 11 00:07:26
- A speaker said the House passed a bill to make data centers pay for added electricity transmission and generation costs, but the Senate left before acting on it 00:08:33
- A speaker described a bipartisan Senate permitting reform deal focused on energy infrastructure, and predicted it would be hard to pass in the lame-duck session 00:09:33
- A speaker noted that the federal surface transportation law expired September 30 and was extended to December 11, and said finding money for a new bill will be difficult 00:10:33
- A councilmember said he looks forward to hearing more about data centers 00:12:02
- A councilmember reported attending the ribbon cutting for the new Hollywood Burbank Airport terminal, which Pasadena co-owns with Burbank and Glendale, and noted Tyron Hampton (Councilmember, District 1) presided as president of the airport board 00:12:56
- A councilmember said the new terminal came in on time and under budget 00:12:56
- A councilmember relayed the Southwest Airlines CEO's remark that larger gate areas allow bigger planes, which are quieter and more energy efficient 00:14:57
State legislative briefing Item 7
State and federal policyAffordable housing
The city's state legislative advocate reported how the governor acted on bills, including a bill on the State Route 710 surplus homes the city has been pushing for and a bill extending the law enforcement mask ban to state police officers. Information only; no action was taken. 00:15:57
- A speaker reported that the governor signed 1,040 of the 1,160 bills that reached his desk and vetoed 120, a veto rate of about 10.3 percent, below his roughly 13.5 percent average 00:15:57
- A speaker said the governor signed AB 2329 on the State Route 710 surplus homes, a bill the city worked on with South Pasadena 00:15:57
- A speaker noted that AB 2329 took effect on signing because of its urgency clause, and said the city hopes to work with Caltrans to speed up its rulemaking 00:15:57
- A speaker said the governor also signed SB 1004, which extends the law enforcement mask ban to state police officers 00:17:03
- A speaker said the governor signed a seven-bill data center package and that more data center and AI legislation is expected next year 00:17:03
- A speaker reported that five of the six bills the city took positions on this year became law, and four of those five were bills the city supported 00:17:03
- A councilmember asked about a bill that would extend the deadline to use certain funds, possibly connected to the Caltrans housing or an affordable housing grant 00:18:20
- A speaker said language had been pulled from AB 2329 late in the process, promised to check, and said the deadline to obligate the funds may not be the problem the city had feared 00:18:45
Signature gathering for the proposed fair housing charter amendment Item 8
Elections and ballot measuresRenters and tenants
Petitions for a citizen initiative to amend the city charter on rental housing have been submitted. Written comments in the packet say it was gathered by a committee called Pasadena Housing Providers and would weaken and eventually repeal tenant protections. Residents complained that paid signature gatherers misrepresented the petition as pro-rent control. The committee discussed whether the city has any role in enforcement or in regulating signature gatherers. The county is checking the signatures, and if the petition qualifies the measure would go on the March 2028 city ballot. Discussion only; no action was taken. 00:19:05
- A councilmember said he asked for the item, and asked whether the city has a role if fraud is being committed in collecting petition signatures 00:20:06
- A councilmember argued that paying gatherers per signature gives them an incentive to say whatever gets a signature 00:20:06
- A speaker said the clerk's office has no enforcement role, and that misrepresentation by circulators is a crime, which he believed is a misdemeanor 00:21:18
- A councilmember said a misdemeanor committed in Pasadena would go to the city prosecutor's office, not the district attorney 00:21:52
- A speaker said the initiative was submitted within the required 180 days, that he raised the complaints with the proponents and reviewed their training materials, and that about 50 people asked to have their names removed 00:22:06
- A speaker said the county's deadline to report on the petition's sufficiency is October 22, after which the clerk will report to the council 00:23:11
- A speaker said a qualifying measure would go on the next regular city election ballot, in March 2028 00:23:11
- City staff said complaints of illegal activity should go first to the Pasadena Police Department, which would investigate and then refer cases to the city attorney's office to decide whether to prosecute 00:23:59
- City staff cautioned that because it is a criminal statute, intent has to be proven, and said the office is unsure whether the Secretary of State would get involved 00:23:59
- Jess Rivas (Councilmember, District 5; Vice Mayor) said she was approached in several places in her district and told things she believes were inaccurate or outright lies 00:25:07
- Jess Rivas (Councilmember, District 5; Vice Mayor) asked whether the city could tell residents who had complained where to report 00:25:07
- A councilmember said the issue comes down to fairness and that the city should support fair elections 00:26:39
- A councilmember urged caution because the issue involves political speech, though paid political speech 00:27:04
- A speaker said each petition section carries a declaration of circulator, and that some circulators were from out of state and some from outside the city 00:27:56
- A speaker corrected the chair's figure of 43,000, saying about 28,000 to 29,000 signatures were submitted 00:29:19
- A speaker said the signatures equal roughly a third of the city's registered voters 00:30:20
- A councilmember floated requiring signature gatherers to register with the city and take a city training, so the city knows who they are if complaints come in 00:48:09
- A speaker said the clerk follows the California Elections Code, which requires no training for circulators 00:49:01
- A speaker said the Legislature removed the requirement that circulators live in the jurisdiction, so they now only need to be 18 00:50:47
- A speaker said he is willing to offer initiative proponents training like the clerk's candidate workshops 00:53:01
- City staff said the city attorney's office would research the idea, citing preemption and First Amendment issues 00:54:31
- A speaker doubted that a local requirement layered on top of the Elections Code would survive a legal challenge 00:56:18
- A councilmember said the committee would look to bring the topic back on a future agenda after consulting offline 00:58:19
- Jess Rivas (Councilmember, District 5; Vice Mayor) said she doubted a fully satisfying fix would be found but called public attention an important first step 00:58:26
AT&T copper landline service Item 5
Phone and internet serviceEmergency preparedness
AT&T is moving to retire traditional copper landlines. A member of the public, writing in after the Eaton Fire, asked the committee to recommend that the council formally oppose withdrawing copper service in high wildfire-risk and poor-coverage areas until a replacement is independently shown to work through multi-hour power outages and mass evacuations. The request also asked the council to urge the FCC and CPUC to require that testing, and to have staff return within 45 days with a draft resolution. The packet letters say copper lines carry their own power and still support alarms and medical-alert devices, and that the FCC has given AT&T a path to discontinue copper service on or after June 1, 2027. The committee asked staff to look into it further; no vote was taken. 00:58:40
- City staff said copper theft is connected and that AT&T can take weeks to repair it 01:02:15
- City staff said the larger driver is a change in technology, as carriers invest in wireless and fiber 01:02:15
- A councilmember said a city ordinance would likely be preempted because this is a national and statewide network 01:03:25
- City staff said the CPUC has stopped disconnections in California until an alternative performs as well as copper 01:03:57
- City staff said AT&T is still contacting Pasadena customers to move them to other products 01:03:57
- City staff said the city has no regulatory role, that in 2024 it pointed residents to the CPUC comment period, and that AT&T has asked the FCC to override state rules, which the FCC has not done 01:05:10
- City staff said Pasadena is not among the first areas where AT&T is trying to move faster 01:06:12
- A councilmember asked staff to look into what the city did in 2024 and whether it took a position, and to check with police, fire and others who rely on communications 01:06:26
- City staff suggested the council could reaffirm its agreement with the CPUC's position that service stay on until there is an adequate replacement 01:08:27
- A councilmember asked how many copper landlines remain 01:09:23
- City staff said about 184,000 residential copper lines remain statewide 01:09:44
- City staff said aging copper infrastructure is no longer necessarily the most reliable service 01:10:01
- A councilmember said that when she called 911 from a cell phone in the city, the call went straight to Pasadena police 01:11:24
Positions on November 2026 local and state ballot measures Item 4
Elections and ballot measures
The agenda recommends supporting local Measures PFD and UP and state Proposition 1, and opposing Propositions 39 and 43. Staff described PFD as the city's 911, fire and paramedic emergency response measure, and the Pasadena City College measure as an extension of existing bonds without raising the current tax rate. Proposition 1 would authorize state bonds for affordable housing. Staff said Proposition 43 would raise the vote needed for local special taxes to two-thirds and restrict property transfer taxes, and that Proposition 39 would require government-issued ID to vote. The committee had voted on this at its prior meeting and voted again to confirm. The recommendations were headed to the full council the next day. 01:13:03
- Jess Rivas (Councilmember, District 5; Vice Mayor) moved to confirm the recommendations to support Measure PFD, the Pasadena City College measure and Proposition 1, and oppose Propositions 39 and 43; Gene Masuda (Councilmember, District 4) seconded. Result: passed, 3-0. 01:16:46
- A councilmember said he thought the written recommendation differed from what the committee had voted on 01:13:51
- City staff presented a support recommendation on Measure PFD, the local 911, fire and paramedic emergency response measure 01:14:15
- City staff presented a support recommendation on the Pasadena City College measure, which extends existing bonds without raising the current tax rate 01:14:28
- City staff presented a support recommendation on Proposition 1, state bonds for affordable housing 01:14:28
- City staff described Proposition 43, recommended for opposition, as raising the vote needed for local special taxes to two-thirds 01:14:56
- City staff described Proposition 39, recommended for opposition, as requiring government-issued ID to vote 01:15:30
- A councilmember said that on one other proposition she had wanted to support it, the chair had not, and the committee left it without a position 01:15:51
- City staff said the recommendations were on the next day's council agenda 01:16:10
- A speaker noted letters received objecting to the city's opposition to the voter ID measure and to the city's support of Measure PFD 01:17:02
Policy on choosing the vice mayor Item 3
Appointments and leadership
The council picks a vice mayor each year at its organizational meeting. By practice, it has chosen the longest-serving councilmember who has not yet held the post, usually for two one-year terms. The city clerk presented a draft policy that would write that practice down. Under the draft, the council keeps the freedom to elect someone else, since the charter requires five votes for any council action, and the same person can serve a second one-year term. The committee leaned toward holding the policy so it goes to the council together with the broader meeting-policy package. 01:17:52
- A speaker said that under a 2024 charter change, an acting mayor is now chosen from among the councilmembers if the mayor's office becomes vacant 01:17:52
- A speaker said the historic practice has mostly been two one-year terms for the longest-serving member who hasn't yet been vice mayor 01:18:52
- A speaker said staff was directed at the last reorganization meeting to return with a succession order 01:20:17
- A speaker read the draft policy, under which the council may elect someone else if the nominee lacks five votes 01:20:17
- Jess Rivas (Councilmember, District 5; Vice Mayor) said that because the charter makes this an election, any policy should only describe the longstanding practice, and she would also be fine taking no action 01:22:52
- A councilmember summarized the policy as one the council would follow but would not be bound by 01:23:27
- A councilmember asked how seniority would be decided between two members sworn in the same day 01:24:06
- A speaker said the policy could become a section of the council's meeting resolution 01:25:51
- A councilmember proposed holding the item until the committee has recommendations on the meeting policy, so the council has one discussion 01:26:12
- A speaker said he had already placed the item on the next day's council agenda 01:26:28
- A councilmember said there is no urgency because Justin Jones (Councilmember, District 3) is next in line 01:26:58
Council meeting protocols and standards of conduct (items 1 and 2 together) Item 1
Ethics and meeting rules
Items 1 and 2, taken together, cover proposed changes to how council and council committee meetings are run and to councilmember conduct, for an eventual recommendation to the full council. The presiding member laid out five areas: Brown Act training, Robert's Rules training and the chair's role, meeting practices (asking staff questions in advance, a 10 p.m. cutoff, speaker order, time limits), the mayor's role in running meetings and notice when the mayor leaves the state, and rules for city-sponsored events and use of city resources. No vote was taken. The clerk will bring back a redline of the meeting policy. 01:27:53
- A councilmember proposed refresher training on the Brown Act, the state open-meetings law 01:28:30
- A councilmember proposed training on Robert's Rules of Order, saying he recalled none on the rules that govern council meetings 01:30:28
- A councilmember argued that the presiding officer should run the meeting and that other members should not try to 01:33:18
- A speaker said Robert's Rules is rule five of the council's meeting rules, and that the municipal code applies it only to advisory bodies 01:34:10
- A councilmember argued that most questions to staff should be asked before meetings, not during them 01:35:48
- A councilmember said, as an aside, that it had been clear at the Public Safety Committee that the city would never use test or loaner drones, and that this was miscommunicated at a council meeting 01:36:51
- A councilmember said the drone matter was not for this meeting, while thanking the chair for clarifying it 01:38:00
- A councilmember proposed formalizing a practice of not starting substantial items after 10 p.m. 01:38:16
- A councilmember criticized the council's practice of setting speaking order by who presses the button first 01:39:17
- A councilmember floated randomizing speaker order, deferring to the member whose district is affected, or rotating the order 01:40:21
- A councilmember supported moving forward on all the proposals but said the speaking order is tricky 01:44:38
- A councilmember said meetings moved faster when agendas listed estimated times for each item 01:45:01
- A councilmember questioned publishing time estimates with the agenda, noting they are already a public record available on request 01:46:07
- A speaker described the time estimates as an informal guide based on speaker cards 01:46:25
- A councilmember argued that the mayor, when presiding, should avoid back-and-forth exchanges and speak after hearing the other members 01:47:50
- A councilmember proposed requiring notice when the mayor is away, similar to the notice required when the city manager is out of the city 01:50:00
- A councilmember proposed another council retreat focused on how the council does its work 01:52:03
- A councilmember argued that the whole council should be informed of, invited to and named on all city-sponsored events, press conferences and giveaways, citing the state ban on using public resources for political activity 01:55:09
- A councilmember proposed city attorney review of statements issued on city letterhead 01:58:31
- A councilmember agreed that the whole council should be invited to city press conferences 02:01:08
- A councilmember said giveaways are harder because the FPPC allows behested payments with disclosure, and questioned whether the city would be preempted 02:01:08
- A councilmember said it is troubling when city resources are used and colleagues are left out 02:03:08
- A councilmember floated barring such city events for a period before municipal elections 02:03:35
- A speaker said proposals not related to meetings should not go in the meeting policy and should instead be drafted as a resolution by the city attorney or city manager 02:05:05
- A speaker offered to bring the meeting-related changes back to the committee as a redline of the meeting policy 02:06:19
Scope and work plan of the committee Item 9
State and federal policy
A discussion of whether the committee should do more on regulatory agencies and on how the city takes part in regional associations of governments, such as SCAG and Metro. The presiding member tabled it for further study. 02:07:54
Public comment
- Opening public comment, items not on the agenda: two speakers. One thanked the city for divesting from weapons and asked the committee to agendize a resolution supporting the eventual abolition of nuclear weapons. The other described a personal harassment complaint and asked how to reach the mayor; the presiding member suggested filing a police report, consulting a civil attorney, and seeking medical help.
- Item 8 (signature gathering for the housing charter amendment): four speakers, two in person and two online. The clerk also reported 24 written letters; the packet includes two from tenants making the same complaint. Three speakers said paid signature gatherers told them the petition was for rent control or would lower rents, when its text would repeal or replace Measure H. Accounts included a petition folded to hide its text, aggressive crowding, and a gatherer asking unregistered people to sign anyway because he was paid per signature. One of the three said she reported an incident to the clerk's office and a state elections body and heard nothing back. One speaker, working with the Pasadena Housing Providers group, defended the effort: he said it submitted 29,000 signatures, expected about 19,000 to be valid, trained gatherers twice a week, and is seeking a balanced rent board, not removing tenant protections.
- Item 5 (AT&T copper landlines): one online speaker, who also wrote in, said state carrier-of-last-resort rules still require AT&T to offer basic phone service. He asked the city to call for independent proof that replacements work during power outages and evacuations before copper is removed from neighborhoods like his.
What's next
- October 22: the county's deadline to report whether the housing charter amendment petition has enough valid signatures. The clerk will then report to the council. If it qualifies, the measure goes on the March 2028 city ballot.
- The city attorney's office will research whether the city could require signature gatherers to register or be trained, given preemption and First Amendment issues. The presiding member said the topic would come back on a future agenda after offline consultation.
- The clerk said he would offer future initiative proponents training like his candidate workshops.
- AT&T copper landlines: staff will look into what the city did in 2024, whether it took a position, and the views of police and fire, then bring the item back.
- The ballot measure positions (support PFD, the Pasadena City College measure and Proposition 1; oppose Propositions 39 and 43) were on the next day's (October 6) council agenda.
- The vice mayor selection policy is to be held and combined with the meeting-policy package. It had been placed on the October 6 council agenda, and the presiding member said it could be pulled.
- The clerk will bring a redline of the council meeting policy back to the committee. Proposals not about meetings, such as city-sponsored events and use of city resources, would be drafted as a resolution with the city attorney or city manager.
- Item 9, the committee's scope and work plan, was tabled to a future meeting.
- Next committee meeting: a special meeting on Monday, November 16, covering both November and December, with another special meeting possible if needed.
- The state advocate will follow up on whether the funding-deadline language survived in AB 2329, and plans to visit November 2. The state Legislature reconvenes December 7. The federal stopgap funding and transportation extensions run through December 11.
Write to the Legislative Policy Committee before its next meeting: publiccomment@cityofpasadena.net