CivicFM
Pasadena

· 9 items

City Council, Tuesday, October 13

On the episode: Turf at two parks, a Ronald McDonald House expansion, and the housing pipeline

This episode was produced with AI from the public recordings of the week's meetings. Links to the sources are in the show notes.

What happened

City Council Tuesday, October 13

9 items

The recording · Agenda · Council Agenda

Domestic Violence Awareness Month proclamation

A ceremonial proclamation declaring October 2026 Domestic Violence Awareness Month, with commendations to Peace Over Violence and a representative of Shepherd's Door, and thanks to the city prosecutor's office, police department and city attorney. 00:01:29

  • The mayor proclaimed October 2026 Domestic Violence Awareness Month on behalf of the council and presented commendations to local organizations. 00:03:10
  • City staff noted the organizations work with the city prosecutor's office and police as resources for domestic violence victims, and that the city also has a victim witness advocate. 00:04:28

Write to the City Council about this

Council marks the death of a longtime city employee

The city manager announced the recent death of an 18-year city employee who began in 2008 in what is now Parks, Recreation and Community Services and was most recently a program coordinator in the Rent Stabilization Department. The council adjourned the meeting in her memory and will send a letter to her family. 00:06:09

  • City staff announced the employee's death and summarized her career, beginning in 2008 in Human Services and Recreation. 00:06:09
  • City staff said she was later promoted into the Rent Stabilization Department, where she served until her death. 00:06:09
  • The mayor said the council would adjourn in her memory and send a letter to her family. 00:07:15
  • A councilmember recalled seeing her at work at the JRCC and offered condolences to her family and coworkers. 00:07:38

Write to the City Council about this

Bond hearing for 2000 East Colorado affordable housing pulled Item 10

Affordable housingBonds and debt

A required federal (TEFRA) public hearing and resolution letting the California Municipal Finance Authority issue up to $42,000,000 (agenda) in tax-exempt bonds for a residential rental project by 2K Colorado, LP at 2000-2030 East Colorado Boulevard and 25 South San Marino Avenue. The item was pulled at the start of the meeting and will be renoticed; two public commenters spoke on it during general public comment. 00:08:07

  • Item 10 pulled from the agenda, to be renoticed; no vote taken. Result: withdrawn. 00:08:16
  • City staff told the mayor before the agenda began that the TEFRA hearing would be canceled. 00:08:07
  • The city clerk repeated later that the hearing was canceled and would be renoticed. 00:43:51

Write to the City Council about this

Dispute over Guanajuato friendship city vs. sister city

State and federal policyEthics and meeting rules

Not an agenda item. After a public commenter asked the council to advance a formal sister-city tie with Guanajuato, Mexico, the mayor said the city had become a Friendship City with Guanajuato, and a councilmember objected that only the full council can extend a sister-city invitation. At the end of the meeting the chair corrected the record, and the two disagreed again over whether the council had seen the letters. 00:14:56

  • The mayor told the commenter he had exchanged communications with Guanajuato's mayor, that the city is now a Friendship City, and that a flag was ordered for display. 00:14:56
  • A councilmember disagreed, and urged the full council to use its power to formally invite Guanajuato to be a sister city. 00:15:18
  • A councilmember argued the sister city organization that let the mayor do this is operating unlawfully because it is not in good standing under state law. 00:16:03
  • The mayor maintained that the mayor has always had authority to recognize friendship cities, noting the item was not on the agenda. 00:16:32
  • The mayor corrected the record, saying he had sent a letter inviting Guanajuato's mayor to consider a friendship city relationship, which was accepted. 02:55:23
  • The mayor said about six other cities have reached out to him, and he will make the same friendship-city suggestion to them. 02:55:23
  • A councilmember objected that the council never got the letters until a member of the public obtained them through a public records request. 02:56:28
  • The mayor said the letters were in his weekly green sheets to the council but that he would double check. 02:56:50
  • A councilmember argued the person Guanajuato was referred to cannot act for Pasadena's sister cities organization because it is not in good standing. 02:57:11
  • The mayor said the matter had been agendized and discussed at length before, and only one sister city committee is recognized by the city. 02:57:56

Write to the City Council about this

Consent calendar Item 1-5, 7, 9

BudgetsAffordable housingHousing supply

Routine items approved in one motion: an information report on an emergency equipment rental for the Path Two 35kV cable replacement, tax-revenue consulting contracts, a Franchise Tax Board data agreement, $2,756,073 (agenda) in federal HOME funds and amended terms for a senior affordable housing project at 280 Ramona Street, FY2027 operating budget amendments adding 2.0 permanent positions, General Fund reserve commitments, and receipt of claims. Items 6 and 8 were pulled for separate votes because of recusals. 00:32:06

  • Gene Masuda (Councilmember, District 4) moved and Jason Lyon (Councilmember, District 7) seconded approval of the consent calendar except items 6 and 8. Result: passed. 00:39:28
  • A councilmember raised the cost of building an ADU or converting a garage, and argued the city could help residents finance ADUs to house people for less than current per-unit costs. 00:37:29
  • The mayor agreed to agendize a look at ADUs and other lower-cost housing options, noting state ADU law has changed. 00:38:30

Write to the City Council about this

Street resurfacing agreement with L.A. County Public Works Item 6

Streets and public works

Authorizes an agreement with the Los Angeles County Department of Public Works for street resurfacing and ADA improvements on streets the city and county share, with the county's share estimated at $1,223,952 (agenda), which is also appropriated into the FY2027 resurfacing program. 00:39:31

  • Motion to approve item 6; the chair named both Jason Lyon (Councilmember, District 7) and Tyron Hampton (Councilmember, District 1) when announcing the second, so who moved and who seconded is unclear. Result: passed. Recused: Justin Jones (Councilmember, District 3). 00:39:46
  • A councilmember recused himself out of caution because his direct employer is L.A. County Public Works. 00:39:31

Write to the City Council about this

Amendments to the FY2027 capital improvement budget Item 8

BudgetsStreets and public works

Amends the FY2027 Capital Improvement Program budget as detailed in an attachment not in the packet. One part (project four, the Raymond Avenue undergrounding/lighting district project, described by staff as $5,000,000 already budgeted) was voted on separately because the mayor owns a home in the district and recused himself. 00:39:46

  • With Victor Gordo (Mayor) recused and Jess Rivas (Councilmember, District 5; Vice Mayor) presiding, motion to approve sub-item 4 of item 8 (Raymond Avenue project); mover and seconder unclear. Result: passed. Recused: Victor Gordo (Mayor). 00:42:08
  • Jess Rivas (Councilmember, District 5; Vice Mayor) moved and Tyron Hampton (Councilmember, District 1) seconded approval of the rest of item 8. Result: passed. 00:43:06
  • The mayor explained he owns a home in a lighting district in the item and recuses on that piece as a matter of practice. 00:39:46
  • A speaker identified the recused piece as $5,000,000 already budgeted for the Raymond Avenue undergrounding project. 00:41:30
  • A councilmember asked whether all the recommendations came from staff, and was told yes. 00:41:53

Write to the City Council about this

Construction tax exemption for Eaton fire repairs adopted Item 12

Disaster recoveryTaxes and fees

Second reading and adoption of an uncodified ordinance, introduced by Tyron Hampton (Councilmember, District 1), exempting qualifying Eaton fire repairs from the city's construction tax. 00:43:06

  • Adopt on second reading the uncodified ordinance exempting qualifying Eaton fire repairs from construction tax (roll call). Result: passed, unanimous. 00:43:38

Write to the City Council about this

Artificial turf vs. grass at Villa Parke and Robinson Park Item 11

Parks and treesPublic healthPollution

Staff recommended replacing the city's only two artificial turf athletic fields, at Villa Parke and Robinson Park, with recyclable artificial turf made without PFAS and filled with natural infill instead of rubber, while continuing to evaluate natural grass for future renovations, and finding the project exempt from CEQA. Staff said Villa Parke is funded in the FY2027 capital budget and Robinson Park is not, so Robinson will need a funding request later. The choice trades playing hours on two heavily used Northwest Pasadena fields against concerns about heat, chemicals, microplastics and cost. After 26 public speakers, the council approved the recommendation 5-3. 00:43:51

▶ Hear it Did the health review consider the environmental commission's report? · 0:45

  • Jess Rivas (Councilmember, District 5; Vice Mayor) moved to approve the staff recommendation (called the vice mayor's motion); a councilmember seconded. Roll call. Result: passed, 5-3. No: Rick Cole (Councilmember, District 2), Jason Lyon (Councilmember, District 7), Steve Madison (Councilmember, District 6). 02:54:34
  • City staff said the recommendation covers only these two fields and does not set citywide policy, and the city will keep 20 natural grass fields. 00:44:18
  • City staff said Robinson Park's turf is also near the end of its life but unfunded. 00:45:36
  • City staff said natural grass would need a four-to-six-month closure to build and an annual three-month closure for renovation. 00:46:38
  • City staff said mowing hybrid grass cuts synthetic fibers, so clippings must go to a landfill rather than green waste. 00:47:39
  • City staff said natural infill runs about 20 to 30 percent cooler than rubber infill but still hotter than grass. 00:48:40
  • City staff noted Palo Alto studied the same three options and its council chose artificial turf. 00:49:48
  • City staff proposed a two-year pilot testing four grass seed varieties on 25,000 square feet of the Villa Parke multipurpose field to improve the city's natural fields. 00:50:55
  • City staff estimated ten-year costs at Villa Parke of about $1.5 million for natural grass versus $2.4 million for turf, which includes $1.2 million to replace it. 00:52:04
  • City staff said Rose Bowl staff believe hybrid renovation costs about the same as installation, estimated at $2.2 million for a field this size. 00:53:19
  • City staff put maintenance cost per playable hour at $5.34 for turf versus $16.15 for grass, because grass would have 2,340 available hours, excluding capital costs. 00:54:26
  • City staff said Public Health is drafting outdoor activity heat guidelines that will apply to both grass and turf fields. 00:55:29
  • City staff said manufacturers make PFAS-free turf with third-party certification, and the contract scope would require proof. 00:57:37
  • City staff reported the school district and Rose Bowl have little field space available to absorb structured league play. 00:58:39
  • City staff corrected the staff report's $975,000 fiscal figure, saying the adopted FY2027 capital budget appropriates $1,125,000 to the project. 01:00:41
  • City staff said Robinson Park would need a separate capital appropriation at a later date. 01:00:41
  • A councilmember questioned the ten-year turf lifespan estimate, since the city's turf has lasted only eight years in each of two cycles. 01:01:45
  • City staff said the Villa Parke field may have only one more season left. 01:02:09
  • City staff estimated Robinson Park, about twice Villa Parke's size, at about $3.1 million for turf and $2.8 million for grass over ten years. 01:04:22
  • City staff acknowledged the Robinson Park figures were put together at the last minute by scaling the formula to field size, and could not explain a discrepancy. 01:05:06
  • City staff said sod would add roughly $100,000 or more per facility and could save about a month of closure. 01:06:59
  • A councilmember said the presentation still felt like it was selling turf, despite the committee's request for a balanced one. 01:08:07
  • A councilmember raised player safety, noting some elite athletes refuse to play on artificial turf, and worried about long-term effects on children. 01:08:40
  • City staff said injury counts in the city's programs are about equal on turf and grass, though the types of injuries differ. 01:09:40
  • A councilmember asked about the surface choice for a dog park in his district. 01:12:21
  • City staff said natural grass is the better choice for dog parks. 01:12:35
  • A councilmember praised the staff presenter but said he brings a bias, while noting the presentation's balance had significantly improved. 01:14:03
  • City staff said rubber infill can reach 150 to 160 degrees, versus about 125 to 130 for natural infill, which is still hotter than grass. 01:15:51
  • City staff said research shows turf products contain contaminants that can disrupt hormones or cause cancer. 02:00:32
  • City staff said the science on how much of those contaminants reach the body is still developing. 02:01:36
  • City staff cited a March 2026 state study of 35 California fields that found no toxic levels in players, coaches, referees or spectators, and called the risk low. 02:02:39
  • The mayor said he had not heard sources cited for the public's claims that the fields are unsafe. 02:03:18
  • City staff said the department reviewed studies the public sent in but discounted many as scientifically weak. 02:03:48
  • City staff said the state study likely did not include newer products like the natural infill being proposed. 02:06:07
  • City staff described the coming heat guidance, which uses wet bulb globe temperature rather than air temperature to set breaks or cancellations. 02:06:43
  • A councilmember questioned why the state study was commissioned and paid for by CalRecycle, a recycling agency. 02:08:20
  • A councilmember raised, as a rhetorical question, whether regulators can be captured by the industries they regulate. 02:09:19
  • City staff said grass baseball fields close two to two-and-a-half months for renovation, and three months is the ideal minimum for soccer and football fields. 02:10:24
  • A councilmember argued natural grass should be the minimum standard for Pasadena. 02:15:13
  • A councilmember said the city underfunds and understaffs grass maintenance, and opposed the staff recommendation while remaining open to alternatives. 02:15:13
  • A councilmember called turf a limited solution for high-use fields like Villa Parke, noting the multipurpose field will stay grass. 02:17:20
  • A councilmember said the field's users overwhelmingly support turf, and moved the staff recommendation. 02:18:22
  • A councilmember said Northwest Pasadena families depend on these fields, and a three-month closure is unacceptable. 02:19:14
  • A councilmember argued active, well-used parks improve neighborhood safety, citing changes near Robinson Park. 02:20:17
  • A councilmember said Villa Parke coaches, parents and players he met were unanimous for turf, and seconded the motion. 02:21:22
  • A councilmember said the data do not show health harm to children from recreational play on turf. 02:22:28
  • A councilmember said turf puts large amounts of microplastics and forever chemicals into the water table and creates heat islands. 02:23:33
  • A councilmember said the lost play time could be solved with school district help, transportation or sod, and voted no. 02:24:34
  • City staff told the questioner the proposed natural-infill product is cooler than the products public speakers described. 02:26:25
  • City staff clarified that CalRecycle is a state agency under CalEPA. 02:26:54
  • A councilmember said he would support the staff recommendation. 02:27:26
  • A councilmember noted the Environmental Advisory Commission report, which the health director said he had not reviewed, cites studies showing potential risk. 02:28:16
  • City staff said his department reviewed only contamination and health impacts, not broader environmental effects. 02:28:32
  • A councilmember argued state law is moving away from artificial turf and the plan could be outlawed by the state. 02:28:46
  • A councilmember argued it would be wrong to accept the risks for kids in the city's poorest areas. 02:34:07
  • A councilmember challenged the characterization of the children near the two parks as the poorest in Pasadena, calling it disrespectful to their families. 02:35:18
  • A councilmember said he would not describe any of the city's children as the poorest of anything. 02:35:29
  • City staff said the specifications, including PFAS-free certification and natural infill, are not yet written into the recommendation but would be included if the council so directs. 02:38:33
  • A councilmember asked that the turf specifications be posted at the park so parents know what children are playing on. 02:38:53
  • City staff said the city applied for a grant for spectator shade structures at Villa Parke, Victory Park, Robinson Park and another park. 02:40:36
  • City staff cited a Glendale study he worked on that found little real heat-island effect from fields of this size. 02:40:36
  • A councilmember said he wished a soil or turf scientist had been part of the discussion, and asked staff to further explore hybrid and organic regenerative fields. 02:41:52
  • City staff said the heat guidelines will apply to any surface, including blacktop, and use portable equipment. 02:44:50
  • A councilmember asked the health director to look into whether a Proposition 65 warning is required for the turf. 02:45:14
  • The mayor said that, given how heavily these two fields are used, the benefits of turf outweigh the drawbacks. 02:46:02
  • The mayor recalled that when the fields were closed years ago, children played in streets and parking lots instead. 02:47:04
  • The mayor recalled that enrollment in youth programs dropped significantly when the fields were closed. 02:48:04
  • The mayor said he supports the recommendation and favors shade sails for players and fans. 02:50:46
  • A councilmember clarified the shade grant covers spectator areas, not the playing field. 02:51:21
  • City staff said sod could cut the closure from three months to two for roughly $100,000 more, as a rough estimate. 02:52:18
  • A councilmember said he would oppose the motion, believing grass can be made to work. 02:53:12

Write to the City Council about this

Public comment

  • About ten people spoke on non-agenda matters. Two raised the Rose Bowl Riders, an organization described as facing eviction after 80 years, and asked the city to pause the eviction and meet with its leadership.
  • One speaker said the city lacks enough motel vouchers for about 300 unsheltered people and that council was not notified when they ran out. The same speaker asked for police data on how quality-of-life laws are enforced against unhoused people, and asked that both be agendized.
  • Two speakers addressed the pulled 2000 East Colorado bond item. One questioned the project's height, parking and lost property tax revenue. The other supported the 100% affordable project and urged the utility to promote plug-in solar under the new state law.
  • One speaker voiced support for a proposed $20,000 for sidewalk improvements under a specific plan the council recently approved for the commenter's area.
  • One speaker asked the council to advance a formal sister-city relationship with Guanajuato and to issue a Sister Cities Day proclamation.
  • A rental property owner said Pasadena's rent-control fair return petition and appeal process is broken and slow. He asked for enforceable deadlines, a way to fix math errors, and a corrected worksheet.
  • One speaker thanked the council for the Black Legacy District and asked for at least $20,000 for banners.
  • One speaker asked again for help filing police reports on a personal matter; the mayor referred her to the police department.
  • Consent calendar: one speaker asked whether the contractor will pay for the emergency equipment rental on item 1. Another did not oppose item 4 but criticized the project's cost growth and urged cheaper housing models such as modular units and motel conversions.
  • Item 11 (turf): 26 people spoke, about 16 against artificial turf and about 10 for it. Supporters included painters' union installers, youth and adult soccer coaches, little league leaders, and a speaker for Spanish-speaking park users; they cited playing time, access for lower-income families, and the cost and wear of grass.
  • Opponents cited heat, PFAS and other chemicals, microplastics, greenhouse gases, injury rates, and environmental justice for Northwest Pasadena. Several urged sod, hybrid, or organic grass pilots instead. The chair of the city's Environmental Advisory Commission questioned the three-month grass closure estimate and the process.

What's next

  • The item 10 TEFRA bond hearing for 2000-2030 East Colorado Boulevard was canceled and will be renoticed.
  • The mayor said a look at ADUs and other lower-cost housing options would be agendized, apparently at the Housing, Homelessness and Planning Committee.
  • Robinson Park's turf replacement is unfunded; staff will return later to request a capital appropriation.
  • If the shade structure grant is awarded, staff will return to the council with a contract.
  • Public Health is finalizing heat-safety guidance based on wet bulb globe temperature; the health director agreed to look into whether a Proposition 65 notice is required for the turf.
  • Staff plans a two-year pilot testing four grass seed varieties on part of the Villa Parke multipurpose field.
  • The mayor said he expects more discussions on fields and sport courts.
  • The meeting adjourned in memory of a longtime city employee, and the council will send a letter to her family.

Write to the City Council before its next meeting: correspondence@cityofpasadena.net

Every claim is checked against the recording and documents linked above. Report an error