CivicFM
Pasadena

· 7 items

Planning Commission, Wednesday, October 14

On the episode: Turf at two parks, a Ronald McDonald House expansion, and the housing pipeline

This episode was produced with AI from the public recordings of the week's meetings. Links to the sources are in the show notes.

What happened

Planning Commission Wednesday, October 14

7 items

The recording · Agenda

Ronald McDonald House expansion: zone change, permit modification, variances, lot merger and tree removal (763/765 S. Pasadena Ave. and 762 S. St. John Ave.) Item 3A

Development projectsZoning and plansHistoric preservation

Ronald McDonald House Charities of Southern California asked to expand its Pasadena hospitality home, which houses families of children getting treatment at nearby hospitals, onto two parcels on S. St. John Avenue: 762 S. St. John Ave. and a vacant parcel (AIN 5719-005-908). The package includes a zone change from RS-4 to RS-4 HH (Hospitality Home overlay) for those two parcels, and a modification of the existing minor conditional use permit to cover them. It also asks for a variance to pave 54 percent of the Pasadena Avenue front yard where 30 percent is allowed, for a circular driveway; a variance and a minor variance for a solid, six-foot fence along St. John Avenue where 50 percent openness and four feet are required; a certificate of exception to merge the four parcels into two; and removal of one Chinese Elm (agenda). Staff described other work: an elevator addition and accessibility remodels to the two Craftsman houses, a replacement Building C of about 1,200 square feet, and a parking lot of up to 25 spaces off St. John with a trash enclosure. Staff said capacity stays at up to 17 families with no change in staff. The commission only makes a recommendation; the City Council decides. The site sits next to a single-family landmark district across St. John Avenue, and the two Pasadena Avenue houses and the St. John building are contributing historic buildings. 00:01:57

▶ Hear it Does the fire department really need the wider driveway? · 0:26

  • A commissioner moved staff's recommendation that the City Council adopt the CEQA exemption and approve the applications, with three added or clarified conditions of approval; a commissioner seconded. At a commissioner's request, the fence-height minor variance (agenda item 5 of the seven applications) was split off, and this vote covered everything else. Result: passed. No: a commissioner. 01:28:26
  • Separate vote on the minor variance allowing a six-foot front-yard fence along St. John Avenue where four feet is allowed. Result: passed. No: a commissioner, a commissioner. 01:28:55
  • City staff explained that the paving variance would allow 54 percent front-yard paving on Pasadena Avenue where the code allows 30 percent 00:03:47
  • City staff said Building C, now about 600 square feet, would be demolished and replaced with a building of about 1,200 square feet for offices, laundry and storage 00:11:06
  • City staff said the facility would keep serving up to 17 families, with no change in the number of families or in staff capacity 00:12:09
  • City staff said the vacant parcel would become a parking lot for up to 25 cars, with delivery access and a trash enclosure 00:13:13
  • City staff said the one protected tree would be removed to make room for the parking lot entrance on St. John Avenue, and replacement trees would be required as a condition 00:18:26
  • A commissioner asked how the public could weigh in on the fencing and the Pasadena Avenue frontage if the designs are only reviewed at plan check 00:21:25
  • The applicant's representative said the organization has been renting the property for 22 years and wants to own it and create a safe, accessible campus 00:32:14
  • The applicant's representative said the house has never had 50 people at once and the realistic maximum is about 35 00:41:38
  • The applicant's representative said the organization has 14 staff, 10 of them part time, with one person on site around the clock 00:42:01
  • A commissioner asked why the project needs much more parking when the site has worked with 13 spaces since 2006 00:42:39
  • The applicant's representative said parking has been a problem, with people parking on Pasadena Avenue and St. John, and the goal is to keep parking on site and out of the neighborhood 00:43:35
  • A commissioner asked that any open metal gate have smooth, well-coated metalwork so children can't get hurt, possibly as a condition of approval 00:45:41
  • The applicant's representative said the new Building C will be built to take rooftop solar and the project is trying to go all-electric but faces power-capacity problems 00:47:02
  • City staff said extending the hospitality home overlay follows a process in the zoning code and is not spot zoning 00:49:12
  • City staff said the site stays subject to single-family standards on noise, deliveries, lighting, setbacks and lot coverage, like any neighbor 00:50:59
  • City staff said the buildings already contribute to the historic district and the city's historic preservation staff reviewed the exterior changes 00:52:16
  • City staff agreed to add a condition requiring fencing materials and illustrations to go to the city's design and historic preservation staff during plan check 01:00:03
  • A commissioner questioned the circular driveway, noting it adds a curb cut and makes the frontage less friendly to pedestrians 01:00:50
  • The applicant's architect said the circular driveway was worked out with the fire department, which will use it to reach the property 01:01:36
  • City staff confirmed the St. John building has been used by the organization, he believed for about six years, without the needed permit, and this process would bring it into the operation 01:03:23
  • The applicant's representative said the team looked at ways to save the elm but found none that would keep the parking lot 01:05:23
  • A commissioner asked staff to clarify the condition saying final on-site and public right-of-way plans are reviewed at plan check, which staff agreed to do 01:07:55
  • A commissioner said she fully supported all the applications, saw no flaws in the findings, and offered to move staff's recommendation 01:14:21
  • A commissioner backed the expanded use but objected that a six-foot fence on St. John would block a passerby's view of the historic building 01:15:23
  • A commissioner said he was also inclined to deny the variance allowing more than half the Pasadena Avenue front yard to be paved 01:16:27
  • A commissioner said he leaned toward approval and gave weight to the families' need for privacy in judging the fence variance 01:17:20
  • City staff explained that the lot qualifies for a circular driveway, but the fire department's need for a wider driveway pushes paving over the limit 01:18:35
  • The applicant's representative said the driveway grew from a 12-foot residential width to about 18 feet at the fire department's request 01:20:16
  • A commissioner said emergency medical access matters even more at a facility like this 01:20:33
  • City staff said the 710 specific plan work is studying Pasadena Avenue and St. John Avenue, including whether Pasadena Avenue could become two-way 01:22:41
  • A commissioner argued that six-foot fences are common around large homes like these and need not be out of character 01:23:25
  • A commissioner objected that a six-foot fence in a front yard is unusual 01:23:46
  • City staff explained that merging the lots creates a double-frontage lot where both street sides count as front yards, which is why the fence variance is needed 01:25:10
  • A commissioner noted that neighbors across St. John would face about 140 feet of fencing 01:25:34

Write to the Planning Commission about this

Subdivision and zoning code amendments for state housing laws (SB 684/1123, SB 450/AB 1061, ministerial lot splits) continued Item 3B

Housing supplyZoning and plansState and federal policy

These amendments to Titles 16 and 17 of the municipal code would carry out state laws. They would allow small-lot subdivisions and housing projects of 10 or fewer lots in residential zones, keep two-unit (SB 9) projects from facing stricter standards than other housing, allow SB 9 projects in historic districts if no historic structure is affected, and process lot line adjustments and subdivisions of four or fewer lots ministerially (agenda). The agenda recommended continuing the item to October 28. Staff instead asked to continue it to a date uncertain so they could fold in new state bills the governor had signed. 01:29:47

  • Motion to continue item 3B to a date uncertain; moved and seconded (movers not clearly identified in the audio). Result: continued, unanimous. 01:30:30
  • City staff asked to continue the item to a date uncertain because newly signed state bills affect the amendments, which will be re-noticed when they return 01:29:47

Write to the Planning Commission about this

Assembly Bill 2576 (historic preservation exclusions for SB 79) update postponed Item 4A

Historic preservationState and federal policyHousing supply

Staff had planned to brief the commission on AB 2576, a state bill the governor signed that takes effect January 1. Staff described it as a cleanup bill to SB 79 that expands protections for historic resources. The briefing was postponed so staff could finish researching the bill. 01:30:45

  • City staff described the bill as a cleanup of SB 79 that expands historic protections, and said staff needs more research before presenting, likely on October 28 01:30:45

Write to the Planning Commission about this

Moving Planning Commission meetings to the first and third Wednesdays Item 4B

Ethics and meeting rules

Staff proposed moving regular Planning Commission meetings to the first and third Wednesday of each month at 6:30 p.m. in the Permit Center Hearing Room. The agenda gives the start as November 18, 2026. Staff said the City Council's move from Mondays to Tuesdays set off a chain of committee schedule changes. The Housing, Homelessness & Planning Committee moved to the second and fourth Wednesdays, the commission's current nights, and the same staff support both. No action was taken because a resolution is needed; it returns October 28. 01:30:45

  • City staff explained that the Housing, Homelessness & Planning Committee now meets on the commission's nights, so the commission needs to move to the first and third Wednesdays 01:31:49
  • A commissioner said he has a standing meeting on first Wednesdays that would conflict 01:32:35
  • City staff said staff recommends keeping the 6:30 p.m. start time 01:32:45
  • City staff said other nights are taken by bodies like the Design Commission and Board of Zoning Appeals, and Mondays run into holidays and leave less time to review packets 01:35:15

Write to the Planning Commission about this

Staff update on hearing room audio-visual upgrades

Government technology

Staff gave a spoken update, not on the agenda, on plans to upgrade the commission's new hearing room: another large screen, smaller tables to tighten the U-shaped layout, built-in microphones, and two cameras, so audiences can see and hear the commissioners. 01:36:53

  • City staff said staff met with an AV specialist and is getting quotes for screens, microphones, new tables and cameras 01:36:53

Write to the Planning Commission about this

Committee reports: Design Commission, Board of Zoning Appeals, CIP Subcommittee Item 5

Development projectsHousing supplyStreets and public works

Members reported on related bodies. The Design Commission reviewed housing projects and has more large ones coming up. The Board of Zoning Appeals ruled on a banquet facility on North Lake Avenue. The CIP subcommittee reviewed projects tied to the North Lake Avenue plan. 01:39:11

  • A commissioner reported that on September 22 the Design Commission held a preliminary consultation on a 12-unit, four-story building at 36 S. Berkeley Ave. and continued again its review of a 32-unit project at 810 N. Marengo 01:39:17
  • A commissioner reported that the Design Commission voted to move its meetings to the first and third Thursdays at 6:30 in the Permit Center 01:39:17
  • A commissioner previewed the Design Commission's next-night review of 225 units at 444 N. Fair Oaks and 153 units at 1946 Colorado, about 400 units in all 01:40:22
  • A commissioner reported that the Board of Zoning Appeals unanimously upheld the hearing officer's approval of a banquet facility on North Lake Avenue 01:41:41
  • City staff said the banquet case had been called up by a council member, some conditions changed, and the board's decision was not called up or appealed to the City Council before the deadline 01:42:24
  • A commissioner reported that the CIP subcommittee met September 23 on projects related to the North Lake Avenue plan, with recommendations coming to the commission 01:43:07
  • City staff announced that the next meeting will include the capital improvement call-for-projects public meeting and an environmental justice element update, plus an open house the next evening at Robinson Park 01:43:34

Write to the Planning Commission about this

Commissioner comments Item 6

Streets and public worksDevelopment projects

Commissioners asked about proposing capital projects, raised concern about how much development is concentrating along Colorado Boulevard, and thanked staff for the move to the new hearing room. 01:44:19

  • A commissioner asked whether the commission can submit its own capital improvement call-for-projects recommendation 01:44:22
  • City staff said a proposal from the full commission needs consensus; otherwise a commissioner can submit one individually 01:44:51
  • A commissioner urged a broader look at how much development is accumulating in one area along Colorado Boulevard 01:45:23
  • A commissioner thanked staff for helping the commission move into the new space 01:46:07

Write to the Planning Commission about this

Public comment

  • Public comment on items not on the agenda: the chair said there were no speakers, in person or online.
  • Item 3A (Ronald McDonald House): two in-person comment turns, three people in all, every one supportive. A representative of the preservation group Pasadena Heritage praised the project and repeated two requests from the group's letter: coordinate the zone change and lot merger with preservation easements being developed for the houses as part of the former Caltrans property sale, and pay close attention to the fencing, gate and landscaping on St. John Avenue so they fit the neighboring historic district. Two longtime supporters of the house, speaking together, cited children's mobility needs, security problems with trespassers, and safer car and van circulation. No one spoke online.
  • After the hearing closed, it was reopened so the Pasadena Heritage representative could answer a commissioner's question. She explained that the easements would protect exterior and interior historic features (fireplaces, original woodwork, pocket doors) in all three houses.
  • A commissioner mentioned written public comment raising concerns about the item's effect on the nearby historic district.

What's next

  • Item 3A: the commission's recommendation goes to the City Council, which makes the final decision on the Ronald McDonald House applications; staff said it will report back.
  • Item 3A: if the preservation easements are recorded before the lot merger, staff said it will work with the applicant to update the legal descriptions.
  • Item 3B (code amendments for state housing laws) is continued to a date uncertain and will be re-noticed; staff is incorporating newly signed state bills.
  • The AB 2576 briefing is expected back on October 28.
  • A resolution moving commission meetings to the first and third Wednesdays at 6:30 p.m. comes back October 28; the agenda gives November 18, 2026 as the start.
  • Next meeting: the capital improvement call-for-projects public meeting with the CIP subcommittee, and an update on the general plan's environmental justice element. The recording gives the date as October 20; the commission's next regular meeting is October 28.
  • Environmental justice element open house at Robinson Park the next evening (October 15), 6 to 8 p.m.
  • The Design Commission reviews 444 N. Fair Oaks (225 units) and 1946 Colorado (153 units) on October 15.
  • Staff is getting quotes for audio-visual upgrades to the hearing room.

Write to the Planning Commission before its next meeting: commentsPC@cityofpasadena.net

Every claim is checked against the recording and documents linked above. Report an error