CivicFM
Pasadena

· 6 items

City Council, Tuesday, October 20

On the episode: Council votes to end riding club's lease; police armored vehicle moves ahead

This episode was produced with AI from the public recordings of the week's meetings. Links to the sources are in the show notes.

What happened

City Council Tuesday, October 20

6 items

The recording · Agenda · Council Agenda

Closed session report

AuditsLawsuits and settlements

The council met in closed session before the public meeting. The agenda listed four closed-session matters: a California State Auditor audit (A), real property negotiations over 360 North Arroyo Boulevard with the Rose Bowl Aquatics Center and the LA28 Olympic organizing committee's diving manager, over price and terms of payment (B), possible initiation of litigation (C), and significant exposure to potential litigation (D). The city attorney reported that items A and B were discussed and there was no reportable action. 00:01:07

  • Closed session report; no action reported. Result: no action. Recused: Jason Lyon (Councilmember, District 7). 00:01:36
  • A councilmember said they did not take part in closed-session item B because their law firm represents one of the parties, and recused from it 00:01:36

Write to the City Council about this

Consent calendar (items 1–6)

EnergyFederal and state fundingAppointments and leadership

Routine items approved together in one vote: a Water & Power resource adequacy program, three police grants, two board and commission appointments, and receiving claims against the city. 00:13:33

  • Rick Cole (Councilmember, District 2) moved approval of the consent calendar, seconded by Gene Masuda (Councilmember, District 4). Result: passed. 00:13:33

Write to the City Council about this

First reading: water waste and water supply shortage ordinance Item 9

Water

First reading of an ordinance amending the city's water waste prohibitions and water supply shortage plans in Title 13, Chapter 13.10 of the Pasadena Municipal Code. These are the city's rules against wasting water and its plans for water shortages. There was no discussion and no public speakers. 00:14:26

  • First reading of the ordinance amending Title 13, Chapter 13.10, introduced by Rick Cole (Councilmember, District 2). Result: passed, unanimous. 00:15:09Ayes: Rick Cole, Tyron Hampton, Justin Jones, Jason Lyon, Steve Madison, Gene Masuda, Jess Rivas, Victor Gordo. Moved by Rick Cole. From the clerk's record

Write to the City Council about this

Police plan to acquire a surplus armored personnel carrier (AB 481 report) Item 10

Surveillance technologyPolicing

An information-only report. The Pasadena Police Department plans to acquire a surplus military armored personnel carrier, a 2008 International MaxxPro of the MRAP type, at no purchase cost through the federal Law Enforcement Support Office (LESO, or 1033) program. State law AB 481 requires the department to report military equipment acquisitions. The chief estimated painting and radio installation at about $15,000 to $20,000, paid from existing fleet funds. Staff said the council did not have to act: unless the council directed otherwise, the department would go ahead with the acquisition. No motion was made, so the acquisition proceeds. 00:15:27

▶ Hear it If the council does nothing, does the armored vehicle deal go ahead? · 1:04

  • No motion was made. Rick Cole (Councilmember, District 2) offered to second a motion if one was made, but none was, so under staff's explanation the acquisition proceeds without council action. Result: no action. 01:06:10
  • City staff presented the department's plan to acquire an armored personnel carrier through the LESO surplus program 00:17:20
  • City staff said the department had posted its notice of intent to acquire such a vehicle on its military equipment web page since May 2024 00:18:25
  • City staff said the department learned on October 7, 2026 that a Northern California agency had the vehicle available, after the annual military equipment report was already done 00:19:27
  • City staff said waiting for the police oversight commission's next meeting in December could delay the transfer and put the acquisition at risk 00:21:37
  • City staff estimated upfitting at about $15,000 to $20,000 for paint and a police radio, with no new funding requested 00:22:41
  • City staff said the department has one armored vehicle now and borrows from other agencies when it needs more, and cited upcoming major events including LA28 00:23:42
  • City staff explained that the council is not required to act on the item but that staff is required to bring it forward 00:26:19
  • A councilmember argued the vehicle is purely military and would damage the department's community reputation, noting the city already has a Bearcat 00:27:41
  • A councilmember stated opposition to acquiring the vehicle even at no cost 00:28:41
  • A councilmember asked about the $20,000 upfit cost despite the vehicle being described as no cost 00:29:02
  • City staff said annual registration would also come from the existing budget, and that the vehicle would be stored out of sight, as the Bearcat is 00:29:26
  • Rick Cole (Councilmember, District 2) shared concerns about the militarization of policing and asked what the 11 incidents involving a borrowed vehicle were 00:30:16
  • City staff described uses such as multi-agency warrant service on armed suspects, evacuations and armed-robbery responses, and said the department is moving to a full-time SWAT team 00:31:14
  • Rick Cole (Councilmember, District 2) said they were not persuaded the city can't keep borrowing a second vehicle when needed, and leaned toward opposing 00:33:02
  • City staff warned that 2028 will bring three of the highest-security events within 360 days, and that federal help will focus on logistics rather than equipment 00:33:37
  • A councilmember questioned the process, saying the item felt like a decision rather than information and could go to the Public Safety Committee 00:35:11
  • City staff explained that the council could direct staff to abandon the acquisition or send it to committee, and that without action the department would proceed 00:35:58
  • City staff said the police oversight commission has approved the department's policy covering armored vehicles 00:36:58
  • A councilmember referred to a recent school shooting in Oregon and said such tools might be needed in situations like that 00:37:07
  • City staff said buying a comparable vehicle would otherwise cost the general fund $250,000 to $350,000 00:39:06
  • The mayor explained that Pasadena hosts a SEAR-1 event, the federal government's highest event-safety category, every year 00:40:54
  • The mayor called the acquisition regrettable but necessary to protect officers, other first responders and the public 00:41:58
  • The mayor said they could not recall any misuse of the Bearcat, which the department has had since 2011, and praised the department's conduct at recent demonstrations 00:42:50
  • City staff said the goal is to show preparedness, not might, and that armored vehicles are kept hidden until needed 00:44:25
  • A councilmember called the Bearcat's incident-free record the most compelling argument for the vehicle 00:47:43
  • A councilmember said use at demonstrations causes them the most anxiety, and asked how the vehicle has been deployed at protests 00:47:43
  • City staff said that at recent demonstrations, including No Kings, the armored vehicle was staged out of sight in an underground garage at the convention center 00:48:12
  • A councilmember noted that the military equipment policy has been reviewed every year without becoming a point of contention 00:49:51
  • The mayor said officers are asked to run toward danger and should be able to do so as safely as possible 01:02:00
  • Rick Cole (Councilmember, District 2) expressed trust in the police department but worried about a slippery slope toward ever-bigger equipment 01:02:50
  • Rick Cole (Councilmember, District 2) said a line should be drawn at some point and that reasonable people can disagree where 01:04:53
  • A councilmember asked that the record show their opposition, while acknowledging it was an informational item 01:05:11

Write to the City Council about this

Brookside Park Stormwater Capture Project: environmental exemption and design Item 7

WaterStreets and public works

The council was asked to find the Brookside Park Stormwater Capture Project categorically exempt from CEQA (the state environmental review law) and to approve its design. The project would build an underground system beneath a Rose Bowl-area parking lot (Lot I) to capture and clean runoff from the Seco Street storm drain, which staff said carries untreated water from about 1,200 acres into the Arroyo Seco. Staff estimated about 86 acre-feet per year of groundwater recharge. Funding includes Measure W grants and long-term Caltrans money. Staff said construction is two to three years away, after the Olympics. 01:06:10

  • Tyron Hampton (Councilmember, District 1) moved the staff recommendation (CEQA categorical exemption finding and approval of the project design), seconded by Gene Masuda (Councilmember, District 4). Result: passed. Recused: Justin Jones (Councilmember, District 3). 01:22:58
  • A councilmember recused from the item out of caution because their employer is involved with stormwater capture projects 01:06:34
  • Rick Cole (Councilmember, District 2) raised a letter-writer's concern that the plans don't match what the city's project website has shown 01:11:10
  • City staff said the website shows the original feasibility concept of about 11 acre-feet, which was later reduced 01:12:18
  • City staff explained that the design now filters much of the water and returns it to the Arroyo at the community's request, which allowed a smaller underground structure; the project is at 90% design 01:12:18
  • City staff denied that the changes were a bait and switch 01:13:23
  • Rick Cole (Councilmember, District 2) faulted staff for not responding to the Environmental Advisory Commission's detailed concerns 01:13:31
  • City staff said the attachments were wrong and the commission's letter concerns the separate Arroyo Seco project 01:14:37
  • City staff said construction is estimated at 18 months, phased at stakeholders' request to start in March or April 01:15:16
  • Rick Cole (Councilmember, District 2) voiced skepticism about concrete-heavy engineering for limited gains 01:16:04
  • Rick Cole (Councilmember, District 2) questioned using a categorical exemption for a project this large instead of a mitigated negative declaration 01:17:05
  • City staff said nine trees would be removed and that they were evaluated under the city's tree ordinance and found not mature or scenic 01:17:13
  • City staff said tonight's action is only CEQA approval and construction is two to three years away 01:18:25
  • City staff said the approval is a milestone for the grant agency and that staff will return to the Municipal Services Committee 01:18:41
  • City staff estimated about 86 acre-feet per year of groundwater recharge 01:19:13
  • City staff described the above-ground features: constructed soil, permeable pavement and a nine-foot planter bed 01:19:13
  • A councilmember asked what drainage structure exists under the parking lot now, saying the existing-facilities exemption was one they weren't entirely convinced by 01:20:03
  • City staff said the existing Seco Street drain carries untreated runoff from about 1,200 acres into the Arroyo Seco 01:20:14
  • A councilmember asked why construction would not start until 2029 when design is 90% complete 01:21:07
  • City staff said construction was set for after the Olympics and that the Caltrans funding is long-term money 01:21:16
  • A councilmember praised staff's community outreach as a model and moved approval of the staff recommendation 01:21:45

Write to the City Council about this

Ending the Rose Bowl Riders lease at Hahamongna Watershed Park Item 8

Parks and treesContracts and purchasing

Rose Bowl Riders, an equestrian club that speakers said has operated for about 80 years, has been on a month-to-month lease at the city's Hahamongna Watershed Park since its tenth amendment expired. Either party can end that lease with 30 days' notice, without cause. The staff recommendation had three parts: a CEQA exemption finding; rescinding the September 21, 2026 termination notice in response to an apparent demand to cure or correct it; and authorizing the city manager to issue a new notice of at least 30 days, with a deadline to vacate by January 31, 2027. Staff cited little or no public benefit in 2025 and 2026 and missing insurance documents. Two earlier requests for proposals (RFPs) failed. Staff plans a new RFP for the site around February 1, 2027, and may bring in an interim operator for boarded horses. The stalls and other improvements belong to the tenant. 01:24:05

▶ Hear it How often did the city actually meet with the riding club? · 0:57

  • Tyron Hampton (Councilmember, District 1) proposed a motion to issue a new RFP on February 1, open for 30 days and widely cast. Result: no action. Recused: Jason Lyon (Councilmember, District 7). 02:19:49
  • Rick Cole (Councilmember, District 2) moved the staff recommendation: CEQA exemption finding, rescinding the September 21, 2026 termination notice, and authorizing a new notice of at least 30 days with a deadline to vacate by January 31, 2027. The second was not identified. Result: passed, 7-0. Recused: Jason Lyon (Councilmember, District 7). 02:31:23
  • A councilmember recused because their firm represents one of the parties in unrelated matters 01:24:16
  • City staff reviewed the history: the city bought the watershed park in 2005, and the lease has gone month-to-month after its amendments expired 01:24:53
  • City staff said that in 2024 the city manager found insufficient public benefit, and that two RFP processes since then were unsuccessful 01:25:58
  • City staff explained that the month-to-month lease requires only 30 days' notice to terminate, without cause 01:27:03
  • City staff said they met with Rose Bowl Riders on site about four times over two years 01:55:11
  • City staff said those meetings covered stable conditions, arena flooding and a tree that needed trimming, and that the issues were addressed 01:55:38
  • City staff said they recused personally from the RFP process and left the evaluation to a staff committee 01:56:20
  • City staff presented slides showing community benefit before 2024 and none in 2025 and 2026 01:59:20
  • City staff said that because the required insurance wasn't in place, the city used another operator, Ride On, for summer camp lessons in 2025 and 2026 01:59:56
  • A councilmember said the public's account and staff's account are far apart, and that the city did not communicate well 02:00:37
  • City staff said staff is redrafting an RFP for equestrian use, drawing on the City of Los Angeles's process 02:02:33
  • City staff said staff would seek an interim operator to care for boarded horses until a new operator is chosen 02:03:12
  • City staff said an earlier lease amendment, made when Metropolitan Water owned the land, transferred the improvements to the tenant 02:03:45
  • City staff said that if the tenant removes the railings, the city would rebuild about 25 stalls, and cited bids for the railing costs 02:04:21
  • A councilmember proposed a motion to have a new RFP go out February 1, open for 30 days and drawn as widely as needed 02:05:47
  • A councilmember criticized that the matter did not go through any of the city's committees or commissions, such as Parks and Recreation, or the Hahamongna advisory group 02:05:47
  • A councilmember called four meetings in two years on matters not related to the use of the site unacceptable 02:06:50
  • The mayor said the decision was not arbitrary and asked staff to walk through the public-benefit record 02:08:20
  • City staff said that in 2022 the lease required lessons for five teens from the city's teen center, who received 68 free lessons 02:09:17
  • City staff said 45 day-camp children got two lessons each in 2023 and 2024, fall and spring lessons were not provided, and 2025–26 lessons lapsed over sexual-abuse liability insurance 02:09:17
  • City staff said the problem was not a lack of insurance but a failure to provide satisfactory proof and required endorsements, such as naming the city as an additional insured 02:10:29
  • City staff said Myrtle Hill Farms, which gave the lessons, was also short on required insurance documentation 02:11:31
  • The mayor pointed to the many insurance deficiencies on the slide as largely why the matter was before the council 02:14:13
  • A councilmember learned that no claims were tendered to the city, though the city was exposed 02:15:08
  • A councilmember criticized layering amendment on amendment, and asked staff whether the city's contracts administrator had been involved 02:15:08
  • Rick Cole (Councilmember, District 2) said near-daily litigation threats limit what the council can say, and that the threats assume the club has a right to occupy the land 02:16:49
  • Rick Cole (Councilmember, District 2) said the benefit people get from the site doesn't create a right to occupy public land indefinitely, and backed the staff recommendation 02:18:52
  • A councilmember asked what amount of public benefit would be acceptable 02:19:59
  • City staff said the city still paid $3,150 for lessons in 2023, and similar amounts in 2024 and to Ride On later 02:21:49
  • City staff said the 45 children came from roughly 600 to 700 day-camp participants 02:22:38
  • The mayor recalled the council choosing equestrian use over soccer fields at the site in the 2000s 02:24:35
  • A councilmember objected that the motion did not set a date for the RFP 02:25:41
  • City staff said staff would strive to release the RFP by February 1 if so directed 02:26:21
  • City staff committed to issuing the RFP as close to or before February 1 as possible, and to telling the council if the date slips 02:27:34
  • A councilmember raised concern about a gap with no operator after January 31, and noted that either party can end the lease on written notice 02:28:49
  • City staff said staff could ask other users in the area to help with boarding and could seek an emergency operator 02:29:23
  • A councilmember noted that the club's original agreement did not come from an RFP 02:29:54

Write to the City Council about this

Public comment

  • Non-agenda public comment (6 speakers, held to a minute and a half each, with full time offered at the end of the meeting): two thanked the council for its North Fair Oaks plan and Black Legacy District and asked the city to identify funding for public art and banners; one criticized city spending priorities and demanded the city stop running ads for Measure PFD; one said the city's 2025 power content label shows 51% fossil fuels against a 33% state average and asked for an explanation; one urged the council to cancel the Flock license-plate reader contract or pause it and collect data; one objected to the Guanajuato sister-city proposal being treated as a friendship relationship
  • Consent calendar: a speaker called for items 1 and 2 did not appear
  • Armored vehicle (item 10): five speakers. Two opposed: one called it a vehicle designed for war that would erode community trust, and the other said the city was skipping the AB 481 process and that they would file a complaint with the state attorney general. Three supported it, among them a police officers' association board member, citing officer safety and cost savings. The clerk reported six letters opposed
  • Brookside stormwater project (item 7): two speakers. One cited a 1921 newspaper account that the site was filled with rubbish and questioned whether a categorical exemption fits; one supported the project as cleaning runoff and adding habitat. The clerk reported four letters opposed or asking for an initial study and one in support
  • Rose Bowl Riders (item 8): 17 speaker cards, about 16 speakers, nearly all urging the city to keep or re-negotiate the lease; one, an equestrian adviser, mainly raised questions about which commission was responsible for the decision and about the advisers' experience. Many were children and teen riders and their parents describing confidence, community and therapy at the barn; club officers and members alleged a lack of transparency, a canceled RFP with no explanation, and questioned the CEQA exemption; speakers mentioned lessons for youth from Hillsides and Five Acres. The clerk reported four letters supporting the staff recommendation or other equine operators, four opposed, and 13 letters from one individual seeking documentation and legal justification for the termination

What's next

  • Rose Bowl Riders must vacate the Hahamongna site by January 31, 2027 under the new termination notice
  • Staff committed to issuing a new RFP for the equestrian site as close to or before February 1, 2027 as possible, and to telling the council if the date slips
  • Staff will look for an interim or emergency operator, and ask nearby users to help, so boarded horses are cared for after January 31
  • Tyron Hampton (Councilmember, District 1) asked staff to share the bids behind the railing and stall replacement estimates
  • Steve Madison (Councilmember, District 6) asked staff to report whether the city's contracts administrator has reviewed this lease
  • The armored personnel carrier will be included in future annual AB 481 military equipment reports
  • Brookside stormwater staff will return to the Municipal Services Committee; construction is expected in about 2029, after the Olympics
  • Staff said they will return to the council separately on the Arroyo Seco stormwater project
  • Upcoming meetings per agenda: closed-session-only council meeting October 26; Finance Committee and City Council October 27; special joint meeting with the county supervisor November 9 at 3:30 p.m.; the November 3 council meeting is to be cancelled

Write to the City Council before its next meeting: correspondence@cityofpasadena.net

Every claim is checked against the recording and documents linked above. Report an error