CivicFM
Pasadena

· 9 items

City Council, Tuesday, November 10

On the episode: Big house survives appeal; council and county take on mental health beds

This episode was produced with AI from the public recordings of the week's meetings. Links to the sources are in the show notes.

What happened

City Council Tuesday, November 10

9 items

The recording · Council Agenda

Hydrogen fueling station items (16 and 17) held Item 16

Contracts and purchasingClimate and sustainability

Item 16 would have authorized a contract with Clean Energy Fuels Corp. for Phase 1 design-build services for a hydrogen fueling station at 159 S. Kinneloa Avenue, not to exceed $6,884,770 (agenda), and a Measure R funding request to Metro; item 17 would have had the city join the First Public Hydrogen Authority, a joint powers authority. Both were pulled from the agenda at the start of the meeting and not discussed. 00:01:39

  • The city clerk announced that items 16 and 17 were being held, would not be discussed that night, and would return later 00:01:47
  • City staff said both items will come back to the full council and staff is weighing whether any portion should first go to a committee 00:31:49

Write to the City Council about this

Veterans Appreciation Week and the Marine Corps' 251st birthday Item 1a

The council proclaimed November 9–15, 2026 Veterans Appreciation Week and November 11 Veterans Day, and marked the Marine Corps' birthday with Marine veterans including city staff. 00:02:05

Write to the City Council about this

Adjournment in memory of a civil rights and labor leader

The council adjourned in memory of a pioneering civil rights leader and labor organizer who recently died. 00:10:00

Write to the City Council about this

Closed session report

Lawsuits and settlements

Before the public meeting the council met in closed session; the agenda listed the city's pending lawsuit against Southern California Edison, one potential case the city might bring, and one case of possible exposure to litigation. 00:14:32

  • City staff reported that no reportable action was taken and only item A, the city's lawsuit against Southern California Edison, was discussed 00:14:32
  • City staff said Steve Madison (Councilmember, District 6) was absent from that session because he recused himself over a potential conflict of interest 00:14:32

Write to the City Council about this

Public comment and council follow-ups Item 1b

Jobs and wages

Open public comment on topics not on the agenda, followed by council announcements and a request about publishing local-hire data on city construction projects. 00:15:00

▶ Hear it Is a surveillance camera's usefulness reason enough to keep it? · 0:42

  • A councilmember announced that Flock license plate reader cameras will be on the council's November 17 agenda 00:31:20
  • A councilmember asked the city manager whether local-hire outreach and tracking data on city projects could be posted publicly on a website 00:32:18
  • City staff said some local-hire information is already on the economic development website and staff will break it down by trade and separate out Pasadena residents 00:32:40

Write to the City Council about this

Consent calendar Item 1c

Contracts and purchasingPublic employees

Routine items 1 through 13b, approved together in one vote, including a new three-year labor agreement with AFSCME, several fleet and service contracts, a $300,000 increase to a disaster recovery consulting contract, Rose Bowl and New Year's Day fee adjustments, and appointments. 00:33:05

  • Jason Lyon (Councilmember, District 7) moved and Tyron Hampton (Councilmember, District 1) seconded approval of the consent calendar. Result: passed. 00:33:29

Write to the City Council about this

Appeal of a large new house at 3140 East California Boulevard Item 14

Development projectsZoning and plans
The existing two-story Spanish revival house at left, and at right a rendering of the proposed 4,955-square-foot Spanish revival residence that would replace it.
Rendering The existing two-story Spanish revival house at left, and at right a rendering of the proposed 4,955-square-foot Spanish revival residence that would replace it. Shown at the City Council, Nov 10 · 00:42:44

A neighbor group appealed the Board of Zoning Appeals' approval of a single-family compatibility permit (No. 7377) for a new 4,955-square-foot, two-story house with a 467-square-foot garage, replacing a roughly 2,116-square-foot home built in 1929. The city's anti-mansionization rules set a neighborhood compatibility size of 3,630 square feet for this lot (35% above the 2,689-square-foot median within 500 feet); exceeding it requires the council to find the design compatible with both sides of the block face. The case tested how the council reads that ordinance, especially what 'block face' means. 00:34:06

▶ Hear it Does 'block face' mean just one side of the street? · 1:06

  • A councilmember moved and another seconded to close the public hearing. Result: passed. 01:37:49
  • Gene Masuda (Councilmember, District 4) moved and Rick Cole (Councilmember, District 2) seconded to approve the staff recommendation: find the project exempt from CEQA, uphold the Board of Zoning Appeals and approve Single-Family Compatibility Permit No. 7377 with conditions, denying the appeal. Result: passed, 6-2. No: Steve Madison (Councilmember, District 6), Victor Gordo (Mayor). 02:07:28
  • The city clerk reported the hearing notice and that the clerk's office received one letter opposing the staff recommendation 00:34:06
  • City staff said the project meets all zoning standards except that it exceeds the neighborhood compatibility threshold 00:35:48
  • City staff explained that the Board of Zoning Appeals approved the project unanimously in August with added privacy conditions 00:37:32
  • City staff said the proposed house would exceed the compatibility size by 1,325 square feet 00:41:39
  • City staff responded to the appeal that the required findings are about design compatibility rather than size 00:47:56
  • The applicant's representative said, for the applicant, that the owner voluntarily accepted conditions for privacy shrubbery around the property and frosted windows facing neighbors 00:51:55
  • The applicant's architect said the existing house is about 100 years old with earthquake damage, so rebuilding made sense 00:53:55
  • The applicant's architect urged the council to weigh compatibility with the larger two-story houses on the north side of California Boulevard 00:54:58
  • A councilmember asked whether the applicant ever met with neighbors to explain the project 00:55:48
  • The applicant's representative answered for the applicant that they offered to meet neighbors at the site and were declined 00:56:14
  • A speaker argued, for the appellants, that the second floor alone is 2,572 square feet with three balconies overlooking neighbors' backyards 01:01:22
  • A speaker said the appellants found discrepancies between the city's lot size figures and county assessor records 01:03:23
  • A councilmember disagreed that privacy falls outside the zoning code, saying setbacks and massing rules reflect it 01:08:10
  • City staff said the tree species for the required screening hedges still needs planning approval 01:08:48
  • City staff said a historic resource evaluation found the existing home not historic because of past alterations 01:10:28
  • A councilmember said he struggles to find a house more than double the existing size compatible with the neighborhood 01:11:17
  • City staff said the 11 north-side houses within the radius average 4,365 square feet 01:11:50
  • City staff reported that since 2021, of 44 projects needing a compatibility permit, 25 were approved administratively, six at public hearing, nine withdrawn and four are under review 01:14:07
  • City staff said the lot is the second widest on California Boulevard and the house would sit over 48 feet back, among the farthest on the south side 01:17:27
  • The mayor asked whether the council has discretion to judge compatibility on an area narrower than the 500-foot radius 01:23:12
  • Rick Cole (Councilmember, District 2) objected that narrowing the area would mean the council making up its own standard 01:22:54
  • City staff said the analysis starts with the block face and may be expanded up to 500 feet 01:23:33
  • City staff read the code's definition of block face as the lots on one side of a street between the two nearest intersecting streets 01:25:59
  • A councilmember summarized the test as whether the house fits in or sticks out when walking the street, and staff agreed 01:29:21
  • City staff pointed to the full ordinance language letting block faces with four or fewer lots include other block faces within 500 feet 01:43:39
  • City staff noted the two neighboring corner lots are nonconforming and sit closer to the property line than code allows 01:47:11
  • Rick Cole (Councilmember, District 2) argued the project meets the standard as staff, the hearing officer and the zoning board all found, and warned against setting a precedent 01:50:06
  • The mayor said he sees a compatibility problem with the immediately adjacent properties 01:51:40
  • The mayor said the ordinance should be revisited because it seems to encourage tearing down homes in established neighborhoods, and questioned the finding on future development 01:53:47
  • A councilmember argued both sides of the block face means both sides of the street, making the house consistent with the neighborhood 01:56:25
  • A councilmember said denying the permit on loose wording reminded him of redlining and noted the owner's time and expense through repeated hearings 01:58:24
  • A councilmember agreed the findings must be made and noted the ordinance says both sides of the street elsewhere, suggesting a clarifying revision 02:00:46
  • A councilmember said he didn't decide right away but waited for staff's conclusions and findings, and he supports staff's position 02:01:30
  • A councilmember said the code defines a block face as one side of a street and he can't read it as both sides 02:02:10
  • A councilmember said the mansionization ordinance's 35% threshold must have meaning and announced he would vote against 02:04:40
  • A councilmember said there is sufficient evidence to make the findings and supported staff 02:05:32
  • The mayor said the ordinance's word may lets the council choose not to expand the area, and he could not make the findings 02:06:28

Write to the City Council about this

Federal WIFIA water infrastructure loan financing Item 15

Bonds and debtWater

Joint action of the City Council and the Pasadena Public Financing Authority approving an installment purchase agreement, indenture of trust, and a federal Water Infrastructure Finance and Innovation Act loan agreement and term sheet for notes of up to $111,050,791 (agenda), plus a $100,000 increase to the PFM Financial Advisors contract for a total of $350,000 (agenda). Approved without discussion. 02:08:12

  • Tyron Hampton (Councilmember, District 1) moved and Jason Lyon (Councilmember, District 7) seconded to approve the staff recommendations for the City Council and the Pasadena Public Financing Authority. Result: passed, unanimous. 02:08:58

Write to the City Council about this

Call for review of Pacific Oaks day-care permit change Item 18

Development projectsChildren and families

A hearing officer approved a modification of Conditional Use Permit No. 2506 for Pacific Oaks Education Corp's existing day-care center at 714 West California Boulevard. Steve Madison (Councilmember, District 6) asked the council to send that decision to the Board of Zoning Appeals for review, citing neighbors' concerns. 02:09:19

  • Steve Madison (Councilmember, District 6) moved and Tyron Hampton (Councilmember, District 1) seconded to call the hearing officer's decision up for review by the Board of Zoning Appeals. Result: passed. Recused: Jason Lyon (Councilmember, District 7). 02:15:10
  • A councilmember recused himself because his law firm represents one of the parties 02:09:54
  • A councilmember said several neighbors in his district see some of the hearing officer's findings as problematic 02:10:19
  • A councilmember noted the hearing officer's findings said a permit modification would remedy a lack of compliance 02:10:19
  • A councilmember disputed that any compromise had been reached, calling it a contested hearing on numerous issues 02:13:55

Write to the City Council about this

Public comment

  • Two speakers, an Altadena fire survivor and the Altadena sheriff's station captain, invited the council to the Altadena Forever Run on January 10, 2027, and reported Eaton fire rebuilding figures: about 280 of 6,000 lost homes rebuilt, 2,500 active construction sites, and 4,000 more permits issued.
  • One speaker, a longtime critic now moving back to the area, praised the mayor's national TV appearance about growing up with parents threatened with deportation.
  • One speaker urged the council to end warrantless mass surveillance such as Flock license plate cameras and opposed expanding toward a real-time crime center.
  • One speaker from the Pasadena Workforce and Trade Coalition asked for public workforce reports, broken out by trade and Pasadena residents, on the transit operations and maintenance facility and the central library retrofit; on item 14 the same coalition asked whether local residents could be hired to build the house.
  • One speaker criticized the city for not lowering flags or issuing a statement for the late civil rights leader, saying it came nearly two weeks after her death, and asked for flags at half-staff.
  • One remote speaker opposed the hydrogen fuel cell project (item 16), arguing battery-electric buses are the trend, and urged traffic calming and fewer lanes on Pasadena Avenue and St. John Avenue.
  • On item 18, a representative of Pacific Oaks said the school had worked with the city for about four years on noise, lighting, fencing and schedule changes, operates about 30% below its permitted enrollment, and asked the city to keep the hearing officer's framework.

What's next

  • Flock license plate cameras are scheduled for council discussion on November 17, 2026.
  • Items 16 (hydrogen fueling station contract) and 17 (First Public Hydrogen Authority membership) will return to the full council; staff may send part through a committee first.
  • Staff said local-hire data on city construction projects will be broken out by trade and Pasadena residents and shared on the economic development website.
  • The Pacific Oaks permit modification (CUP No. 2506) goes to the Board of Zoning Appeals for review.
  • The mayor and several councilmembers suggested revisiting the neighborhood compatibility ordinance or clarifying its block-face wording; no formal direction was given.

Write to the City Council before its next meeting: correspondence@cityofpasadena.net

Every claim is checked against the recording and documents linked above. Report an error