CivicFM
Pasadena

· 6 items

Housing, Homelessness & Planning Committee, Wednesday, October 14

On the episode: Turf at two parks, a Ronald McDonald House expansion, and the housing pipeline

This episode was produced with AI from the public recordings of the week's meetings. Links to the sources are in the show notes.

What happened

Housing, Homelessness & Planning Committee Wednesday, October 14

6 items

The recording · 2026-10-14 Special Housing, Homelessness and Planning Committee Agenda

Approval of September 14 special meeting minutes

A motion to approve the minutes of the committee's September 14, 2026 special meeting, with two corrections raised from the dais, was moved and seconded. No vote was heard before the chair moved on to new business. 00:00:39

  • A councilmember asked for two corrections: the draft minutes list Jason Lyon (Councilmember, District 7) as absent even though they show him seconding a motion, and they mention the Public Safety Committee somewhere on the second page 00:00:52

Write to the Housing, Homelessness & Planning Committee about this

How the city handles concessions and waivers under the state density bonus law Item 1

Housing supplyZoning and plansAffordable housing

This was an information report the committee had asked for. Under the State Density Bonus Law, a developer who sets aside homes at below-market prices can build more units than local zoning allows. The developer can also ask for up to five concessions from development standards, such as floor area or height, and for as many waivers as needed, such as setback or building-separation rules. The staff memo says the city's ability to deny these requests is very limited. Pasadena currently has 23 major housing projects (70 or more units each) submitted or under construction, totaling 4,160 units. Of those, 1,066 (25.6%) are bonus units and 1,525 (36.7%) will be affordable (agenda). Staff is updating Zoning Code Chapter 17.43 to remove the old separate Affordable Housing Concession Permit process. Concessions and waivers would instead be reviewed together with a project's other approvals. That change is expected at City Council in early 2027. Information only; no vote. 00:01:48

▶ Hear it What does it take to deny a density bonus concession? · 1:04

  • City staff said the committee had requested the report and that staff had tried several times to schedule it 00:01:48
  • City staff said staff is updating the zoning code to comply with state law and to clarify how concessions and waivers are reviewed 00:02:15
  • City staff explained that applicants can request up to five concessions and an unlimited number of waivers, and that the city's ability to deny them is very limited 00:03:19
  • City staff reported 23 major housing projects in the city totaling 4,160 units, 18 of them with density bonus units and seven of them 100% affordable 00:06:24
  • City staff said the most common requests are for floor area, setback, open space, and height 00:06:24
  • City staff added that parking is missing from the list because parking reductions usually come automatically and don't have to be requested as a concession 00:07:12
  • A councilmember questioned why central parts of the city count as very low vehicle travel areas, and said they remained skeptical 00:09:24
  • City staff explained that the designation means residents there drive fewer miles per person, based on census data and state modeling 00:09:54
  • A councilmember asked staff to move quickly past background the committee already knew, given the length of the agenda 00:11:23
  • City staff said that after a 2021 court case, cities can no longer require financial information to prove a concession is needed for a project to be feasible 00:11:32
  • City staff said in answer to a question about historic resources that the more direct the impact, the more defensible a denial would be 00:15:38
  • City staff said a taller building next to a shorter historic one might not meet the threshold for an impact on a historic resource 00:15:48
  • City staff said the San Francisco project was ultimately reapproved at six stories, and that the chance a project could be redesigned to meet the code is not a valid reason to deny it 00:17:40
  • City staff noted that in the Jurupa Valley case the city approved all but about three of the waivers and was still challenged 00:18:35
  • City staff said Glendale's denial failed because no specific findings of adverse impact were made, and that the state housing department said it had listened to the whole council meeting 00:20:28
  • City staff said, when asked, that neither the state nor the court gave guidance on what would have justified a denial 00:21:13
  • City staff said staff could find no example where the state or a court agreed a concession could be denied; the Santa Monica case was resolved when the applicant redesigned 00:21:34
  • City staff explained that the public, applicants, or cities can ask the state housing department for a determination, and that cities often reversed course after its letters because of litigation risk 00:24:24
  • City staff said the state housing department contacts the city fairly often because it hears from applicants 00:24:34
  • The committee chair said the state housing department now has enforcement authority, and called its technical assistance letters arbitrary and capricious because they act as precedent without clear standards 00:25:22
  • City staff said the updates to Chapter 17.43 and the concurrent-processing section are expected at City Council early next year 00:27:23
  • City staff noted that concessions used to go to the hearing officer through a separate permit, and now go through design review 00:27:57
  • The committee chair remarked that the city has little to no discretion in design review 00:28:21
  • A councilmember called it disappointing that the waived standards often support livability, and asked whether the city publicly tracks its progress toward its state housing targets 00:41:43
  • City staff said the city tracks projects through several phases and reports to the state every year; staff was not sure whether the numbers are posted online as a dashboard 00:42:46
  • City staff said many market-rate and mixed-use projects are moving slowly or are on pause, while 100% affordable projects with funding are moving ahead 00:45:06
  • A councilmember concluded that the roughly 4,000 pipeline units may not all be built, or not soon 00:45:28
  • City staff noted that pipeline numbers run higher than in the past because applications now stay valid longer 00:46:21
  • A councilmember urged working with state legislators, rather than fighting Sacramento, on a bill that would return some local control to cities that produce affordable housing 00:47:53
  • The committee chair acknowledged a different view on local control but said common ground is key 00:48:56
  • A councilmember asked how many of the pipeline units are in 100% affordable developments; staff said they would gather that breakdown 00:49:04
  • A councilmember said the state has won the fight over local control and that the city's changes to projects now come at the margins 00:50:29
  • A councilmember criticized one-size-fits-all state laws such as SB 79, and said the city delayed its implementation to spread density in a way that suits Pasadena 00:51:29
  • A councilmember said District 7 alone has 936 units in the pipeline, with about 1,500 more within a block or two, and described an emerging urban village along Colorado 00:53:05
  • A councilmember relayed complaints from tenants of affordable and supportive housing who lack parking and pile up street parking tickets, and asked staff for ideas 00:54:11
  • A councilmember argued that much of the region's land goes to cars and that underground parking adds $40,000 to $50,000 per space to the cost of a unit 00:57:45
  • City staff said state law treated parking as a cost barrier, and that the city cannot require parking but the transportation department could look at managing street parking 01:00:52
  • The committee chair said Pasadena is built out and has a strong affordable housing record, and objected to cookie-cutter state mandates 01:04:00
  • The committee chair argued that car ownership and car use should not be conflated, and that the regulations are arriving before adequate transit exists 01:06:02
  • A councilmember said they would not vote to spend public money on litigation or on refusing to follow state housing law, while advocacy in Sacramento continues 01:11:24
  • The committee chair said many proponents of the state legislation have spent little time in Pasadena and model it on denser cities like San Francisco 01:12:28

Write to the Housing, Homelessness & Planning Committee about this

Update on major housing projects under review Item 2

Development projectsHousing supplyAffordable housing

Staff gave its twice-yearly update on major projects submitted in the past six months: over 50 homes, or over 25,000 square feet of nonresidential space. The last update was in March. All five new projects were residential, and staff said all of them use the density bonus. (1) A school district site on Pasadena Avenue in District 1: 110 units, all affordable, on 5.3 acres, with 223 parking spaces, under a state law that lets school districts build housing for staff. (2) 444 North Fair Oaks Avenue in District 5: 225 units, 33 affordable, four to six stories, just under 300 parking spaces. (3) 452 North Los Robles Avenue, the former 99-cent store site, in District 3: 289 units, 44 affordable, up to seven stories, 532 parking spaces. (4) 1946 East Colorado Boulevard, the Cameron's site, in District 7: 154 units, all affordable, with 77 parking spaces. (5) 2006 East Colorado Boulevard in District 7: 144 units, all affordable, with 60 parking spaces; consolidated design review is tentatively set for November. Neighbors are now notified at the preliminary consultation stage of design review. Information only; no vote. 01:19:28

▶ Hear it Why review projects that are wildly out of code? · 0:38

  • City staff said the update covers projects over 50 residential units or over 25,000 square feet of nonresidential space, and that only residential projects came in during the last six months 01:23:08
  • City staff described the school district project as 110 units, all affordable, on 5.3 acres, in two- to three-story townhouses and stacked flats 01:23:08
  • The committee chair disclosed owning property very close to the 444 North Fair Oaks site and offered to step out while it was discussed 01:26:26
  • City staff described 444 North Fair Oaks as 225 units with 33 affordable, at about 121 units per acre, subject to objective design standards 01:26:55
  • City staff described the former 99-cent store site project as 289 units with 44 affordable, reaching seven stories, with 532 parking spaces 01:28:07
  • City staff described the Cameron's site project as 154 units, all affordable, at four to six stories 01:30:08
  • City staff described 2006 East Colorado as 144 units, all affordable, on a 40,000-square-foot site, with 60 parking spaces 01:31:36
  • City staff noted that a recent code amendment requires public notice for preliminary consultation, and that staff plans this update every spring and fall 01:32:38
  • City staff explained that preliminary consultation happens before a project takes shape, and that projects often don't yet meet code at that stage 01:33:53
  • A councilmember questioned why projects that are far out of code go to preliminary consultation at all 01:34:45
  • City staff said staff must bring a project forward once the applicant submits the required items 01:35:09
  • City staff confirmed that preliminary consultation counts toward the state's five-meeting limit 01:35:21
  • The committee chair called the requirement another imposition from Sacramento 01:35:59
  • A councilmember asked about the status of the former 99-cent store project; staff said it has been submitted for preliminary consultation but not yet scheduled 01:36:27
  • City staff said a city-hosted community meeting would count as one of the five meetings, but an applicant-hosted one would not 01:37:11
  • City staff advised against a councilmember hosting a meeting on the project because it could count toward the five-meeting limit, and offered to look into it 01:37:33
  • A councilmember asked for a public list of the developers behind each project 01:38:53
  • City staff said staff sends a monthly list of new projects with the applicant and case planner, keeps an online development activity map, and could add council field representatives to the distribution list 01:40:18
  • The committee chair said, responding to public comment, that the state acted because of other communities rather than Pasadena, and objected that SB 79 applies to only five counties 01:46:33

Write to the Housing, Homelessness & Planning Committee about this

Proposed changes to predevelopment plan review rules (pushed to next meeting) Item 3

Development projectsZoning and plans

Staff proposed removing the provision that lets a councilmember or the planning director ask for a large project's predevelopment plan review to be presented to the City Council as an information item. Under state law (SB 330), that presentation would count as one of the five public meetings allowed for a qualifying housing project. Staff would instead give this committee general updates on newly submitted projects, which would not count toward the limit (agenda). Staff is seeking a recommendation. The item was not heard and was pushed to the next meeting after a committee member had to leave. 01:45:47

  • Defer the item to the next meeting (by consensus; no formal motion). Result: continued. 01:46:08
  • City staff said staff is seeking a recommendation on the predevelopment plan review item 01:46:04

Write to the Housing, Homelessness & Planning Committee about this

New regular meeting schedule Item 4

The committee set its regular meeting for the second Wednesday of each month, and reserved the fourth Wednesday for special meetings as needed. A resident said the public can comment on topics not on the agenda only at regular meetings. 01:48:21

  • Jason Lyon (Councilmember, District 7) moved, seconded by Justin Jones (Councilmember, District 3), to hold regular meetings on the second Wednesday of the month, with the fourth Wednesday reserved for special meetings as needed (the chair stated the motion afterward, and said the vote was unanimous among the members present, after a councilmember had left). Result: passed, unanimous. 01:49:08
  • City staff proposed the second Wednesday of each month for regular meetings, with the fourth Wednesday held for special meetings as needed 01:48:37

Write to the Housing, Homelessness & Planning Committee about this

November special meeting date and the year-end work plan Item 5

Because the November regular meeting date falls on Veterans Day, staff proposed a special meeting on Thursday, November 19, and will poll members to confirm it. Staff then laid out the committee's planned agenda for the rest of the year. November: the quality of affordable units (a joint housing and planning item), the quadrennial inspection program together with hoarding cases, and the annual count presentation. December 9: possible school safety zones, a check-in on the continuum of care, the environmental justice element, and models for the year-round shelter. The possible October 28 special meeting was dropped because no items were ready. No formal vote. 01:49:23

  • City staff proposed Thursday, November 19 for a special meeting because the regular Wednesday falls on Veterans Day 01:49:23
  • A councilmember said November 19 is open on their calendar 01:50:25
  • A councilmember asked for a poll so members can check their calendars 01:51:08
  • City staff said staff is continuing work on the year-round shelter and will return in December on the potential school safety zones 01:52:50
  • City staff said the November discussion of affordable unit quality will be a joint housing and planning item covering how the city permits, inspects, and finances such projects, but not specific projects 01:54:13
  • City staff said the December school safety zone item will include maps and heat maps, and staff wants direction on whether to pursue an ordinance 01:55:20
  • City staff said staff has toured a tiny home village, will tour a motel conversion next week, and plans to see a newly built shelter before discussing shelter models 01:56:25
  • A councilmember asked whether the council could influence who is appointed to the new continuum of care board; staff said the council does not under the current governance structure, and the new board is not expected until early next year 01:57:42
  • A councilmember called the work plan ambitious and doubted the committee would get through all of it 01:58:49
  • City staff said staff has nothing ready for an October 28 special meeting 02:00:02

Write to the Housing, Homelessness & Planning Committee about this

Public comment

  • Item 1 (density bonus concessions and waivers): about six people spoke. Most supported more housing and density. One welcomed the state's role, citing 577 unhoused people in the city, 322 of them without shelter. Another cited a severe shortage for renters and the value of living near transit. A third urged Pasadena to copy cities that streamline approvals, such as Anaheim. A fourth said capital is moving into affordable and senior housing and urged the city to trust the state's data. One speaker raised concerns about a proposed East Colorado project seeking five concessions and two waivers to reach 78 feet where 39 is normally allowed, and urged the city to use its traffic study guidelines, as Santa Monica did.
  • One speaker on item 1 raised a funding gap of just under $500,000 for repairs at a specific affordable housing property (Summit Grove). The chair said the comment was off the item and asked him to contact the chair's office.
  • Speaking out of order on items 4 and 5, one resident asked for regular meetings twice a month and few special meetings, so the public can raise non-agenda items. She also asked for updates on the year-round shelter, unmet bad-weather shelter needs, and the impact of the federal HR 1 on unhoused residents.
  • Speaking out of order on item 5, a homeowner in an affordable ownership development asked the committee to agendize a review of the city's relationship with the nonprofit Heritage Housing Partners. He said four of its last five projects faced construction-defect lawsuits, and that the nonprofit is not letting owners sell or rent their units. He suggested a dedicated housing department staffer for low-income projects.
  • Item 2 (major projects): three people spoke. One renter praised walkable neighborhoods and the city's e-bike rebate. Another supported the new projects for adding residents, tax revenue, and students, and asked for a public tracker of progress on housing targets. A third questioned whether the city is weighing the cumulative effects of growth on traffic and infrastructure, citing the 532 parking spaces planned on Los Robles, and criticized the design of the 2006 East Colorado project.

What's next

  • The predevelopment plan review item (agenda item 3) moves to the next meeting; staff is seeking the committee's recommendation.
  • Regular meetings will be held on the second Wednesday of each month, with the fourth Wednesday reserved for special meetings as needed.
  • Staff proposed a November special meeting on Thursday, November 19, and will poll members, including Rick Cole (Councilmember, District 2), to confirm.
  • The possible October 28 special meeting is not expected to be held because staff has no items ready.
  • Planned for November: the quality of affordable units (joint housing and planning item), the quadrennial inspection program with hoarding cases, the annual count presentation, and possibly a regular reporting item.
  • Planned for December 9: possible school safety zones (with heat maps, and direction sought on an ordinance), an update from the interdepartmental team on complaints and a dashboard, a continuum of care check-in, an environmental justice element update, and year-round shelter models.
  • Staff expects to bring updates to Zoning Code Chapter 17.43 (density bonus) and the concurrent permit processing section to City Council early next year (memo: early 2027; presented to the Planning Commission September 9, 2026).
  • Staff will gather a breakdown of how many pipeline units are in 100% affordable projects.
  • Staff will look into whether a councilmember-hosted community meeting would count toward the five-meeting limit and report back to a councilmember.
  • Staff will add developer names to future project update presentations, and may add council field representatives to the monthly new-projects distribution list.
  • Staff plans to present the major projects update every spring and fall.
  • Consolidated design review for 2006 East Colorado Boulevard is tentatively scheduled for November.
  • A speaker said they will hold a district meeting with city staff on Monday about development along Colorado.

Write to the Housing, Homelessness & Planning Committee before its next meeting: commentshhpc@cityofpasadena.net

Every claim is checked against the recording and documents linked above. Report an error